The category of "Most Popular Reality Game" was included from the first season of The People Choice Awards.

 

Season 1

Nominees: Virtual Big Brother, Virtual Survivor, Virtual Top Model, Virtual Mole, Virtual Glass House.

Winner: Virtual Big Brother.

 

Season 2

Nominees: Virtual Big Brother, Virtual Survivor, Virtual Mole, Virtual Glass House, Virtual Photographer.

Winner: Virtual Big Brother.

 

Season 3

Nominees: Virtual Big Brother, Virtual Top Model, Virtual Amazing Race, Virtual Mole, Virtual Glass House.

Winner: Virtual Big Brother.

 

Season 4

Nominees: Virtual Big Brother, Virtual Survivor, Virtual Top Model, Virtual Mole, The Choice.

Winner: Virtual Big Brother.

 

Season 5

Nominees: Virtual Big Brother (Virtual Reality), Virtual Survivor (Virtual Reality), Virtual Mole (Virtual Reality), Virtual Big Brother, (Play.VirtualGames), Virtual Survivor (TCA Games).

Winner: Virtual Big Brother (Virtual Reality).